Are Video Game Delays Good or Bad?
Apr 9, 2023 | 1 VotesMaking video games is tricky; many things can go wrong when finishing them on schedule. Let's quickly discuss how game delays affect the game's creation, whether for the good or bad.
The Bad
To begin with, game delays happen when game development cannot meet the allotted time and expectations of publishing the game. There are many reasons why delays have to happen, and the result of such delays can be very harmful and costly to the game's publisher. Delays can also be a way to save the development project, but whether this may end up for good or not depends on the game's success afterward.
One of the most famous disaster cases of a delayed game release is John Romero's Daikatana. The game was an ambitious FPS adventure project with a time-traveling futuristic Samurai who dispatches his enemies with the legendary Daikatana sword. It was initially announced in 1997 to be released late that year or early 1998. Of course, the expectations of the gamers and fans of Doom, Quake, and other id titles were high, as everyone knew who John Romero was. Daikatana was to be released by Ion Storm, which Romero established after his fallout with id.
It's easy to list why a game release date getting delayed could turn into a horrible thing, but using Daikatana as an example can make things more transparent. Romero decided to operate the Quake engine initially he was using at id, which was (at the time) already starting to grow outdated and running a stiff competition from the better Unreal game engine. So, Romero decided to switch to the Quake 2 engine. The problem was the Quake 2 engine was a massive leap from the original Quake engine, so everything they initially made using the Quake engine had to be scrapped, and everything had to be revamped. At this point, the game had already passed its original intended/promised release date.
The game suffered from a poor design, primarily if the protagonist NPC companions get killed, the game is over, and the player has to restart/reload once again. Also, many bugs were quite blatant, like the NPCs getting stuck trying to walk through walls and, in many cases bringing the game to a halt, especially during tense moments of action. The game was innovative, though, with a lot of cool and neat features (at the time), but it took so much time to complete, and 1999 went by, adding another year to the then super lagging game release. Daikatana was finally released in 2000 after being delayed for almost three years. Three years!
What made matters worst was the marketing and the hype generated for the game. Ion Storm promised the gaming world a super innovative FPS adventure that fell short of gamer expectations and delivery date. Coming out in 2000 had it competing with other games that delivered better graphics and used better game engines. The game became a great disappointment to the gaming industry, especially coming from John Romero, who ultimately failed to deliver the super awesome game he promised. Daikatana has gone down in gaming history as one of the most (if not the most) hyped delayed games ever released and unable to deliver.
The moral lesson of this sad tale is those game companies should stay faithful to their promises. If there are unavoidable delays, admit it to the waiting customers with all honesty and work to bring out the game as expected or much more. Over-marketing and super hyping a fun (and the company) to cover up for development problems will not end up in anything good for everybody.
The Good
Famous writer Alan Wake goes on vacation with his wife Alice in Bright Falls. An unknown group grabs Alice and Alan has to search through the area to find and rescue her. Using a variety of firearms and a flashlight, Alan can protect himself against the shadowmen and their followers, who are vulnerable to light. Alan Wake is primarily a third-person view action-shooter adventure and mystery game with excellent graphics, gameplay, and sound. The game is so good that even IGN gave it a rating of 9.0, as Alan Wake will go down in gaming history as one of the best games ever released.
A Remedy Games title, Alan Wake had the misfortune to be delayed several times and took around eight years to develop. The game was initially designed as an open-world game, not the story-driven linear progression adventure that finally came out. The game uses both the Max Pane engine and the game editor. Still, the real clincher is basing the game on real locations in North America found in Washington, Oregon, and British Columbia, and implementing all these places into the town of Bright Falls.
The game in development was introduced in 2005 with a tentative schedule for its final release. Funded by Microsoft, Remedy continued work on the game till around 2008, when they realized that an open-world approach to a mystery thriller game would not work because, in this kind of gaming, the story is the focal point, just like in a storybook or novel.
From that point on, Remedy had to refocus the game's direction. Unlike Daikatana, Alan Wake uses the same game engine it started with. All the materials that had already been made were slotted or rearranged to fit the now story-driven orientation of the game; practically, almost nothing was wasted. Despite so much time in development, Remedy steered the hype for the game more towards an enigmatic mystery than outright bravado, which Ion Storm did with Daikatana. The game was released in 2010 for the Xbox 360, but the promised PC version was canceled. This was another significant delay.
Remedy, however, continued with the PC version, finally getting Microsoft to release the game on Steam in 2012. So the development started somewhat from 2004 to 2012. Eight years to complete. Despite all these delays, Alan Wake turned out to be the award-winning AAA game it was meant to be. Combining extra quality work and low-key hype saved Alan Wake's bright day.
Looking Forward
Forspoken is a coming-up game to be released on January 2023. Supposedly to be released the previous year, the game has been delayed. Unlike older games that have been out for some time, it would be difficult to speculate why the game has been postponed since no developer/publisher would be idiot enough to trumpet their woes to prospective customers. What we can observe would be the immediate reaction from the expectant gaming community.
With Forspoken, speculations abound, but since game release delays have constantly burned the industry, current-day reactions are quite different since Ion Storm's folly in the late 1990s. A delay of a few months to even a year can now be written off as the developer ensures that the game will possess the quality to meet the expectations provided by any hype the publisher's marketing department has presented. The usual public reaction would be "meh". Marketing is essential and should not be taken lightly—a lesson learned from Ion Storm's ad campaign.
Forspoken, however, is a new adventure featuring a young New York resident named Frey Holland who has to explore the magical land of Athia and fight her way through with her excellent supernatural abilities. Presentations of the game have shown superb graphics, audio, and gameplay as good (or better) than Alan Wake. Developed by Luminous and to be released by Square Enix, time will tell whether the game will be able to deliver. After all, it was initially pegged for 2022 and ended up getting delayed several times.
At times, it is far better to explain things through examples as simply listing reasons as to why may not be enough to convey to you (the reader) the intense effect of what a game release date delay entails. Suffice it to say, and it can be good, it can be harmful, but do keep in mind not to make the customers mad.